Blog
CALL US TODAY

(253) 544-3651

GAF vs. CertainTeed

GAF vs. CertainTeed: A Comprehensive Comparison

GAF vs. CertainTeed

When it’s time to replace your roof, selecting the right shingle brand is a crucial decision that will impact your home’s durability, aesthetic appeal, and resale value. Among the top contenders in the roofing industry are GAF and CertainTeed, two brands known for their quality, innovation, and extensive product offerings. This comprehensive comparison will delve into the key aspects of each brand, helping you make an informed decision about which shingles are right for your home.

GAF and CertainTeed are two of the most recognized names in the roofing industry, both offering a range of shingles that cater to different needs and preferences. Whether you’re looking for budget-friendly options or high-end luxury shingles, these brands have something to offer. However, understanding the differences between GAF and CertainTeed is essential to ensuring that you choose the right product for your roof. In this blog, we’ll explore their histories, product offerings, material quality, warranties, and more to help you make the best choice.

Brand Overview: GAF and CertainTeed

GAF Overview

History and Market Presence

GAF, founded in 1886, has grown to become the largest roofing manufacturer in North America. The company is known for its innovation, particularly with its Timberline® series, which has become the best-selling shingle in North America. GAF’s commitment to quality is reflected in its robust warranties and the stringent standards it maintains for its certified contractors.

Reputation and Customer Satisfaction

GAF enjoys a strong reputation for producing reliable, durable shingles that withstand various weather conditions. The company’s focus on customer satisfaction is evident in the extensive training and certification programs it offers to contractors, ensuring that only the top 3% of roofing contractors are qualified to install their products under the Golden Pledge® warranty.

CertainTeed Overview

History and Market Presence

CertainTeed, established in 1904, is another heavyweight in the roofing industry. The company offers a wide range of building products, including roofing shingles, siding, insulation, and more. CertainTeed is particularly known for its high-quality Landmark® and Presidential® series, which are favored by homeowners seeking premium roofing options.

Reputation and Customer Satisfaction

CertainTeed has built a reputation for producing high-quality shingles that are both durable and aesthetically pleasing. The company’s commitment to innovation is reflected in its cutting-edge technology and eco-friendly initiatives. CertainTeed’s SELECT ShingleMaster™ contractors are among the best in the industry, offering homeowners peace of mind with top-tier installation and warranty options.

Product Range Comparison

GAF Shingles

Types and Styles of Shingles

GAF offers a diverse range of shingles, catering to different budgets and aesthetic preferences. The most popular series include:

  • Timberline®: GAF’s flagship product line, Timberline shingles are available in a variety of styles, including Timberline HD®, Timberline HDZ®, and Timberline American Harvest®.
  • Designer Shingles: For homeowners seeking a unique, high-end look, GAF’s Designer series includes options like Glenwood®, Grand Sequoia®, and Camelot®.
  • 3-Tab Shingles: GAF’s most budget-friendly option, 3-tab shingles are available in the Marquis WeatherMax® and Royal Sovereign® lines.

Color Options and Customization

GAF shingles come in a wide array of colors, allowing homeowners to choose the perfect match for their home’s exterior. The company’s Advanced Protection® Shingle Technology also ensures that the shingles maintain their color and integrity over time, even in harsh weather conditions.

CertainTeed Shingles

Types and Styles of Shingles

CertainTeed also offers a comprehensive range of shingles, with some of the most popular options being:

  • Landmark®: Known for its exceptional durability and aesthetic appeal, the Landmark series is available in various sub-categories, including Landmark PRO, Landmark TL, and Landmark Premium.
  • Presidential®: This luxury series offers the look of wood shake roofing with the durability of asphalt shingles. The Presidential Shake® and Presidential Shake TL® are top choices for homeowners seeking a premium product.
  • 3-Tab Shingles: CertainTeed’s 3-tab shingles are available in the XT™ 25 and CT™ 20 lines, providing an affordable option without compromising on quality.

Color Options and Customization

CertainTeed offers an extensive palette of colors across its shingle lines, with unique options that cater to a variety of architectural styles. The company’s ColorView® technology allows homeowners to visualize different color combinations, ensuring they find the perfect match for their home.

Material Quality and Durability

GAF Shingles Durability

  • Wind Resistance: GAF shingles are designed to withstand winds of up to 150 mph, depending on the product line.
  • Impact Resistance: Certain GAF shingles, like the Timberline® ArmorShield™ II, are rated for Class 4 impact resistance, providing superior protection against hail and debris.
  • Algae Resistance: GAF’s StainGuard Plus™ technology helps prevent unsightly algae growth, keeping roofs looking clean and new for longer.

CertainTeed Shingles Durability

  • Wind Resistance: CertainTeed shingles are also highly resistant to wind, with Landmark® shingles rated for winds up to 110 mph, and other premium lines offering even higher resistance.
  • Impact Resistance: CertainTeed’s Presidential Shake® and Landmark® lines offer Class 4 impact resistance, ensuring long-lasting durability in hail-prone areas.
  • Algae Resistance: CertainTeed’s shingles are treated with StreakFighter® technology, which provides long-lasting protection against algae growth.

Comparison of Manufacturing Process and Warranties

Both GAF and CertainTeed use high-quality materials and advanced manufacturing processes to produce their shingles. GAF’s Advanced Protection® Shingle Technology and CertainTeed’s QuadraBond™ adhesive system are examples of innovations that enhance the durability and longevity of their products.

In terms of warranties, GAF offers several options, including the Golden Pledge® Warranty, which provides 50 years of coverage on materials and up to 25 years on workmanship. CertainTeed’s SureStart™ PLUS warranty offers similar coverage, but with some differences in terms of exclusions and conditions, particularly regarding ventilation requirements.

Installation Process and Ease

GAF Installation

  • Availability of Certified Contractors: GAF’s Master Elite® certification is awarded to the top 3% of roofing contractors, ensuring that only the most skilled and experienced professionals install their shingles.
  • Ease of Installation: GAF shingles are designed for ease of installation, with features like the LayerLock™ Technology that helps contractors install shingles more quickly and accurately.

CertainTeed Installation

  • Availability of Certified Contractors: CertainTeed’s select ShingleMaster™ program certifies top-tier contractors, ensuring high-quality installation for their premium products.
  • Ease of Installation: CertainTeed shingles are also designed for ease of installation, with features like the NailTrak® technology that help ensure precise nailing.

Comparison of Contractor Support and Installation Quality

While both GAF and CertainTeed offer robust support for their certified contractors, the smaller pool of GAF Master Elite® contractors may result in more consistent installation quality. However, CertainTeed’s larger network of SELECT ShingleMaster™ contractors provides homeowners with more options when selecting a roofing professional.

Cost Comparison: GAF vs. CertainTeed

Initial Cost

  • Cost per Square Foot or Bundle: On average, GAF shingles tend to be slightly more affordable than CertainTeed shingles. However, prices can vary depending on the specific product line and region.
  • Installation Cost Differences: Installation costs are typically similar for both brands, although GAF’s LayerLock™ Technology may reduce labor costs due to faster installation times.

Long-term Value

  • Maintenance and Repair Costs: Both GAF and CertainTeed shingles require minimal maintenance, but CertainTeed’s premium lines may have higher repair costs due to their complexity.
  • Return on Investment (ROI) When Selling a Home: Investing in high-quality shingles from either brand can increase your home’s resale value, with CertainTeed’s luxury lines potentially offering a higher ROI.

Regional Pricing Variations

Pricing can vary significantly by region due to factors like shipping costs, local demand, and contractor availability. Homeowners should obtain multiple quotes to ensure they are getting the best deal.

Warranties and Guarantees

GAF Warranty

  • Different Levels of Warranties: GAF offers several warranty options, including the Standard Warranty, System Plus Warranty, and the Golden Pledge® Warranty.
  • Coverage Details: The Golden Pledge® Warranty is the most comprehensive, offering 50 years of material coverage and 25 years of workmanship coverage, with additional protections against misapplication. GAF’s warranties are generally seen as more homeowner-friendly due to fewer exclusions and more lenient terms.

CertainTeed Warranty

  • Different Levels of Warranties: CertainTeed offers a variety of warranty options, such as the SureStart™ Warranty and the SureStart™ PLUS Warranty.
  • Coverage Details: CertainTeed’s warranties provide similar coverage to GAF, but with stricter requirements regarding ventilation and installation. The SureStart™ PLUS Warranty covers materials for up to 50 years and includes labor for a specified period, but the terms may vary based on the specific product and installation conditions.

Comparison of Warranty Coverage, Limitations, and Transferability

While both GAF and CertainTeed offer robust warranties, GAF’s warranties are often considered more flexible and customer-friendly, particularly regarding ventilation requirements. CertainTeed’s warranties are still strong but may require more stringent adherence to installation guidelines to maintain full coverage. Homeowners should carefully review the terms of each warranty to ensure they understand the conditions and limitations.

Performance in Different Climates

GAF Shingles in Various Climates

  • Performance in Hot Climates: GAF shingles, particularly those with Advanced Protection® Shingle Technology, perform exceptionally well in hot climates. Their UV-resistant materials help prevent cracking and fading, making them a reliable choice for homes in sunny regions.
  • Performance in Cold Climates: GAF shingles are designed to resist cracking in cold weather, maintaining their integrity even during harsh winters. The Timberline® series, for example, has excellent performance in snowy regions, providing strong protection against ice dams.
  • Performance in Humid Climates: In humid environments, GAF shingles resist moisture-related issues like algae growth, thanks to the StainGuard Plus™ technology. This makes them a great option for homes in coastal areas or regions with high humidity.

CertainTeed Shingles in Various Climates

  • Performance in Hot Climates: CertainTeed shingles, especially the Landmark® series, are known for their durability in hot climates. Their thermal-resistant materials help reduce heat absorption, which can lead to lower energy costs for cooling.
  • Performance in Cold Climates: CertainTeed shingles are designed to withstand extreme cold, with excellent flexibility to prevent cracking. The Presidential Shake® series is particularly noted for its resilience in snowy and icy conditions.
  • Performance in Humid Climates: CertainTeed’s StreakFighter® technology provides robust protection against algae, making these shingles a strong choice for humid climates where moisture can lead to unsightly streaks and premature wear.

Regional Performance Insights

Both GAF and CertainTeed shingles are engineered to perform well in a variety of climates. However, GAF’s Advanced Protection® Shingle Technology and CertainTeed’s premium lines offer specific advantages depending on the region, making it important to consider local climate conditions when selecting your shingles.

Environmental Impact and Sustainability

GAF’s Commitment to Sustainability

  • Recycling Programs and Eco-Friendly Products: GAF is committed to sustainability, offering shingle recycling programs that reduce waste and environmental impact. The company also produces ENERGY STAR®-certified shingles that help improve energy efficiency in homes.
  • Energy Efficiency and Green Certifications: GAF’s cool roofing products, like the Timberline® Cool Series, reflect more sunlight and reduce heat absorption, leading to lower energy consumption for cooling. The company is also committed to reducing its carbon footprint through various green initiatives.

CertainTeed’s Commitment to Sustainability

  • Recycling Programs and Eco-Friendly Products: CertainTeed is equally committed to environmental stewardship, with a focus on producing eco-friendly building materials. The company’s EcoScorecard™ provides transparency about the environmental impact of its products, helping homeowners make informed choices.
  • Energy Efficiency and Green Certifications: CertainTeed offers a range of ENERGY STAR®-certified shingles, such as the Landmark Solaris® line, which is designed to reflect more solar energy and reduce cooling costs. The company’s commitment to sustainability is also evident in its manufacturing processes, which aim to minimize waste and reduce energy consumption.

Comparison of Environmental Initiatives

Both GAF and CertainTeed are leaders in sustainability within the roofing industry, offering eco-friendly products and initiatives that reduce environmental impact. Homeowners who prioritize green building practices can confidently choose either brand, though specific products like GAF’s Timberline® Cool Series or CertainTeed’s Landmark Solaris® may offer additional benefits in terms of energy efficiency.

Which One Should You Choose?

When comparing GAF and CertainTeed, it’s clear that both brands offer exceptional roofing solutions, each with its own unique strengths. However, after careful consideration, GAF stands out as the preferred choice for many homeowners due to its consistent quality, innovation, and strong network of certified contractors.

Why GAF Might Be the Better Choice

GAF has established itself as a leader in the roofing industry, not just through the high quality of its products but also through its rigorous contractor certification program. GAF’s Master Elite® contractors represent the top 3% of roofing professionals, ensuring that your roof is installed by the best in the business. This level of expertise, combined with GAF’s innovative technologies like StainGuard Plus™ for algae resistance, makes it a particularly strong choice for homeowners who prioritize long-term durability and reliability.

In addition, GAF offers a comprehensive range of warranties that are designed to provide homeowners with peace of mind. The Golden Pledge® Warranty, for instance, offers robust protection and is backed by a company with a longstanding reputation for standing by its products.

CertainTeed: A Strong Contender

While CertainTeed also offers high-quality shingles and a variety of premium options, its focus tends to be more on luxury and aesthetics. CertainTeed is an excellent choice for those who are looking for specific high-end styles and are willing to invest in a premium product. However, when it comes to a balance of quality, performance, and the assurance that comes with a highly selective contractor program, GAF takes the lead.

Both GAF and CertainTeed provide outstanding roofing options, but for homeowners who seek a combination of innovative technology, strong warranties, and installation by top-tier professionals, GAF emerges as the superior choice. CertainTeed remains a strong contender, especially for those with a preference for luxury and aesthetics, but GAF offers a level of consistency and reliability that is hard to match.

Here’s a table that provides an overview of the key aspects of GAF and CertainTeed before moving into the decision-making section:

FeatureGAFCertainTeed
History & ReputationFounded in 1886, largest roofing manufacturer in North America, known for innovation and reliability.Founded in 1904, recognized for high-end, aesthetically appealing products.
Product RangeWide range including Timberline® series, Designer shingles, and 3-Tab options.Comprehensive range including Landmark®, Presidential®, and 3-Tab shingles.
Durability & PerformanceAdvanced Protection® Shingle Technology, high wind and impact resistance, StainGuard Plus™ algae protection.Strong performance with wind and impact resistance, StreakFighter® algae protection.
Aesthetic AppealOffers a variety of styles and colors, strong focus on both performance and visual appeal.Focus on luxury and high-end aesthetics, extensive color options and premium styles.
WarrantiesGolden Pledge® Warranty offering up to 50 years of coverage, fewer exclusions, strong contractor backing.SureStart™ PLUS Warranty, comparable coverage but stricter requirements, robust but with more exclusions.
Installation QualityInstalled by Master Elite® contractors, top 3% in the industry ensuring high installation standards.Installed by SELECT ShingleMaster™ contractors, top 7.5% of contractors, but with more variability.
SustainabilityENERGY STAR® certified products, strong recycling programs, commitment to reducing environmental impact.Equally strong commitment to sustainability, EcoScorecard™ for transparency, ENERGY STAR® certified products.
Best Suited ForHomeowners seeking durability, innovation, and reliable installation with strong warranties.Homeowners prioritizing luxury, aesthetic appeal, and are willing to invest in premium roofing.

Ultimately, the best choice will depend on your specific needs and priorities. We recommend consulting with a professional roofing contractor to help you decide which shingles will best suit your home.

Contact Us for Professional Support

Don’t delay- contact us today to schedule a free, no-obligation roofing inspection and estimate. At Chase Construction Northwest, Inc., we are committed to helping you find the best roofing solution for your home. Whether you choose GAF or CertainTeed, our team of experts will ensure a flawless installation that meets your highest expectations. You can reach us at 254-445-8950 or by filling out our estimate form. We look forward to hearing from you soon and thank you for considering us as your roofing service provider.

FAQs

1. Which brand offers better warranties, GAF or CertainTeed?

A: Both GAF and CertainTeed offer excellent warranties, but GAF’s Golden Pledge® Warranty is often considered more homeowner-friendly due to fewer exclusions and more lenient terms.

2. Are GAF shingles more affordable than CertainTeed shingles?

A: Generally, GAF shingles are slightly more affordable than CertainTeed shingles, making them a great choice for homeowners on a budget.

3. Which brand is better for harsh weather conditions?

A: Both brands perform well in harsh weather, but GAF’s shingles, particularly those with Advanced Protection® Shingle Technology, are known for their superior wind and impact resistance.

4. Can I mix and match shingles from GAF and CertainTeed?

A: It’s generally not recommended to mix shingles from different manufacturers, as they may have different specifications and performance characteristics.

5. How do I choose the right shingle for my home?

A: Consider your budget, local climate, and aesthetic preferences. Consulting with a certified roofing contractor can also help you make the best decision.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top